I’m No Longer a Physicalist in the Mind-Body Dualism Debate

Hey, what’s up? First of all, yes, today is Trans Day of Remembrance. This is me acknowledging that while also explicitly stating that my own lack of personal participation is simply because, for my own mental health, I need to not be looking at or producing memorials for trans siblings who left us too soon…

Hey, what’s up? First of all, yes, today is Trans Day of Remembrance. This is me acknowledging that while also explicitly stating that my own lack of personal participation is simply because, for my own mental health, I need to not be looking at or producing memorials for trans siblings who left us too soon right now.

Last post on here was me showing off my reliquary for my first ever vial of estradiol valerate. This post is me continuing to go down the rabbit hole which that opened for me. I’m fairly public with sharing I was raised as one of Jehovah’s Witnesses. A vital part of the religion (at the time at least–it may be different now as it’s an incredibly different beast than it was 20 years ago) is that a person does not have a soul, but is a soul. The idea being that there isn’t a separate essence that continues on after we die, death is simply the end.

When I was in college, we would sometimes have friendly debates or discussions about mind-body dualism. You know, as you do. In these discussions I always held the position of physicalism, that everything is physical, the mind is simply what the brain does, and is not separate. A bit stereotypical for a budding physicist, perhaps, but I don’t think that’s where I was really coming from. I held that position, because it was familiar to me. I could reconcile it with what I’d believed growing up as a Jehovah’s Witness that there is no separation between the soul and the living body.

My attempt to connect with whatever spirituality I may have left in me as a 41 year old who’s been an agnostic atheist at this point for longer than I’ve been anything else has involved using my “HRT cartouche” as a thing to touch when leaving my home as a reminder to myself of who I am, what I’ve become, and what I want to be out in the world. What I’ve decided I need to accommodate that is a separation of the mind and body, or something external to my physical form that I aspire to be, become, or enact. This feels stereotypical to the point of being trite, but I also need my whatever-that-is to be a woman. I’m not a woman, I’m non-binary genderqueer, but I was assigned male at birth and I want to meet somewhere–in the middle, off to the side, I don’t really know–with my whatever-that-is.

To be clear, I’m uncomfortable with how much this smacks of the “born in the wrong body” narrative that gets thrown around a lot as, I assume, a satisfying enough explanation for cis people so they don’t have to think about it too hard and doesn’t seem to be a non-distorted reflection of the experience of most trans people I know personally. Even if it was, I’m still perverting it to better fit my own non-binary experience. To absolve myself of whatever guilt I feel for all that, I want to make it clear that I don’t think this is real, I think this belief is a tool that will (hopefully) be useful, for me.1

I’ll end with a ham-fisted attempt at a Jesus-like parable. Sometimes, physicists will debate whether or not electric fields are “real”. I’ve always thought this was a little goofy, because electric field theory is a valuable tool that produces invaluable results. Whether or not there really is a physical field that in some way embodies the directions and magnitudes we’ve assigned to it as a mathematical convenience isn’t really important, is it? We can use electric fields to make accurate predictions of empirical results or develop usable models for specific physical configurations of matter and charge.

All the same, I don’t think it’s important that there’s some divine feminine whatever-that-is that actually exists and is connected in some way to my physical existence. I want to actualize my ideal self, and I want to develop a working model of a hypothetical spiritual framework that helps me accomplish that. If an adjustment will benefit me and my community, I’ll keep it. If a tweak feels like it might be damaging to me or, importantly, again, my community, I’ll reject it. If the whole framework becomes more of a bane than a boon, it’ll be scrapped entirely.

  1. Fuck, I’m incorporating Peter J. Carroll into my spirituality an awful lot for someone who described Liber Null & Psychonaut as “some random dude’s barely edited shower thoughts from the 1970s” aren’t I? ↩︎

Leave a Reply